New announcement. Learn more

CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS (ICAEW)

News and advice to help make your property business a success

Landlords TaxProperty TaxLandlords Tax ReturnsProperty Tax ReturnProperty AccountsLandlords AccountsTax ReturnsChartered AccountantsOnline AccountantOnline BookkeepingOnline Tax ReturnsYour Online AccountantYour Online BookkeeperBusinessadviceAccountingTaxCashflowProperty AccountantSmallbusinessBusinesstipsTaxplanningVATCgtFurnished Holiday LettingsInheritance TaxLandlords AccountantPropertyProperty bookkeeperTaxreturnAnnual Exempt AmountBusiness RateCapital AllowancesCapital gains tax propertyComplianceDeductibleexpensesDisincorporationEmployment AllowanceFinanceFinancialmanagementHoliday Lets TaxLandlords FinancialMaking Tax DigitalMakingTaxDigitalMileage AllowanceMobilephonesOverlapreliefPensionPprProperty Company TaxProperty Tax Deductible ExpensesPropertyallowanceRent a Room ReliefSDLTSmall BusinessTimetoPayVAT invoice60 day capital gains limitAbolitionclass2AccrualsbasisAcquisitionsAdvisoryfuelratesAIAirBnBAllowable Business ExpensesAlphabet sharesAmapAnnual Tax on Enveloped DwellingsAppealArtificial intelligenceAssessmentAsset disposalAssociated CompanyAssociated Company Tax RulesAutumnstatementBad DebtBad Debt Tax ReliefBaddebtsBadgesoftradeBeancounterBenefits in KindBreakeven PointBudgetBusiness adviceBusiness asset defermentBusiness coachBusiness ContinuityBusiness EntertainmentBusiness ExpensesBusiness Rates ReliefBusiness tipsBusinessgrowthBusinesstypesBuy or Lease EquipmentBuytoletCapital Allowances for CarsCapitalallowancesCapitalexpenditureCar Capital AllowancesCarry Back LossesCashbasisChange of Tax BasisChatGPTCIS SchemeCommon TenantCompanies ExpenditureCompanies HouseCompany Account DeadlinesCompany Account FilingCompany Strike OffCompany Tax Efficient PropertyCompanyassociationCompanyloanstaxfreeCompulsory Strike OffConstruction Industry SchemeContacthmrcContentmarketingCorporation Tax LossesCorporation Tax New RegimeCorporation Tax RatesCorporationTaxCostsCryptocurrencyCustomerlistimplicationsDeductible Business ExpensesDepreciationDevelopmentDirectorsDirectors LoansDirectorsloansDisallowable Business ExpensesDiscoveryDividend allowanceDividend Allowance ReductionDividend PlanningDividendallowanceDividendsDLADomestic Items Tax ReliefDormantcompanyEmployee DiscountEmployee managementEmployeecompensationpaymentsEmployeeOwnershipTrustEndoflifeplanningEnquiryEnterpriseResourcePlanningEntrepreneurmindsetEquityExpensesExpenses Allowed For TaxExtrabenefitEyetestsFHLsFlippingFurnished Holiday Lets TaxGift AidGiftsGrowthhacksHelp to pay tax billsHICBCHMO Licensing FeesHMRC complaintsHoldoverreliefHoliday Lettings TaxHow to apply for a Business LoanHow to Extract ProfitHumourHybridIhtexemptionsIllegaldividendsInfluencersInheritance Tax Nil Rate BandInterestreliefInterestrestrictionInvestment Property TaxJoint TenantKeypersoninsuranceLandlord RepairsLandlords Self AssessmentLate vat registrationLBTTLeadgenerationLeadmagnetLeanbusinessmodelLetting Agent DisbursementsLetting Agent RecharresLettings ReliefLimitedcompanyLoaninterestLong Lets TaxLongserviceLTTMainresidencereliefManaged LetsManagement accountingMaritalhomedivorceMarriage allowanceMarriageallowanceMileage paymentMinimumwageMixedusesdltMortgage costsMortgage Interest ReliefNew propertyNewcompanycarfuelratesNewnicrulesNIC 2023 to 2024NIC savingsNicdisregardNicreductionNMWNmwerrorsNon-taxableNudgeletterOptiontotaxvatOverpayment ReliefPaperformPartnershipPartnershipbusinessesParttimePatternofoccupancyPAYEPAYE by Direct DebitPayrollingPenaltypointsPension Payments Tax ReliefPensioncontributionsPensionsPerformance-reviewsPeriodofgracePeriodsofabsencePersonal financePersonalallowancePersonalguaranteesPostcessationreliefPretradingexpensesProfitProfit-and-lossProfitAndLossProperty AllowanceProperty Development CompanyProperty IncorporationProperty Investment CompanyProperty investor accountsProperty investor tax tipsProperty LettingProperty Rental BusinessProperty TradingPropertycompanyRecharges by Estate AgentsRegularpaymentsReimbursedexpensesRent your driveRentalRentaroomResearch & DevolopmentResidence ReliefResidential property gainsResidentialsdltRetail stock controlRetainedprofitsRevenueRoom for rent taxRtiSASalarySDLT changesSection 455 TaxSection455taxSelective Licences LandlordsSelf AssessmentSelf-employednicSelfemployedSeperationServicechargesSettlementslegislationSimplified ExpensesSmallbizSmallbusinessratereliefSoftwareSpring BudgetStaffpartiesStamp dutySuccessJourneyTax Allowance on DrivewaysTax AllowancesTax DeadlinesTax Filing DeadlinesTax Free ChildcareTax free incomeTax on Company VansTax positionTax ReliefTax tips for landlordsTaxbillpaymentsTaxconsequencesTaxincentivesTaxpositionTaxpositionassetsTaxreliefTaxreliefsTaxsesTerminationpaymentsTipsTrade professionalTransfer AssetsTransfer Assets Between SpousesUmbrellacompanyUndisclosedincomeUnpaid RentVAT Bad Debt ReliefVAT DeadlinesVAT DisbursementsVAT PenaltiesVAT registrationVatpenaltiesVatregisteredVatregistrationthresholdWellbeing
TAGS

When does period of ownership for PRR start?

When does period of ownership for PRR start?

Private residence relief (PRR) removes the capital gains tax charge that would otherwise arise on a gain on the disposal of an only or main residence. The relief shelters the gain to the extent that it has been lived in as a main residence. Qualifying periods of absence and the last nine months of ownership are also covered by the relief if the property is not occupied as an only or main residence throughout.

Where a house is built and lived in as a main home until it is sold, establishing the period of ownership for PRR purposes is straightforward. However, what if the taxpayer buys a plot of land, demolishes the existing house and builds a new house in which they live until it is sold? This is precisely the question which was considered by the Upper Tribunal in a recent case in which the taxpayers emerged victorious.

The taxpayers (Gerald and Sarah Lee) purchased a plot of land on 26 October 2010. They demolished the existing house and built a new house in which they lived as their main residence from 19 March 2013 until the house was sold on 22 May 2014. They claimed PRR on the full amount of the gain on the basis that they had occupied the new house as their only or main residence throughout the period that they owned the house.

HMRC argued that they need to consider the whole period of ownership from 26 October 2010 to 22 May 2014, not just the period for which the dwelling house was occupied as the main residence. Consequently, only the portion of the gain relating to the period from 19 March 2013 to 22 May 2014 was eligible for PRR as this was the period in which they lived in the new house as their only or main residence. Applying this interpretation, they had amended the Lees’ Self Assessments to show a gain of £541,821 relating to the period from 26 October 2010 to 18 March 2013. The First-tier Tribunal upheld the Lees’ appeal, concluding that for PRR, the relevant period of ownership for which occupation as main residence was required was the ownership of the dwelling house. The legislation was silent on ownership of the land.

HMRC appealed to the Upper Tribunal.

The Upper Tribunal upheld the decision of the First-tier Tribunal on the basis that the statutory interpretation of the legislation was that it referred to ownership of the dwelling house not of the land.

Implications

This is a good result for the taxpayer and particularly for self-builders. Applying the reasoning adopted by the First-tier and Upper Tribunals, it would be possible to buy a plot of land which was left empty for some years and then build a house on that land. As long as the house was occupied throughout as an only or main residence, PRR would apply to the whole gain.